NDURE Fined Over Rs 20 Branded Shopping Bag Charge
A consumer protection court in Peshawar has penalized the footwear retailer NDURE with a fine of Rs 40,000 for imposing a Rs 20 fee on a branded shopping bag. The charge was deemed an unfair trade practice by Judge Nasrullah Gandapur, who ordered the company to refund the customer’s Rs 20 payment and pay Rs 20,000 as compensation, alongside a Rs 20,000 fine paid to the government.
Legal Ruling Against Charging for Branded Bags
The court’s decision arose from a complaint filed by a customer, Sarah Sial, who purchased shoes at NDURE’s University Road store in Peshawar. She was charged for a plastic bag featuring the NDURE logo, which the court identified as a promotional item funded by customers rather than the brand itself.
Judge Gandapur emphasized that customers cannot serve as marketing agents for a company and should not be charged for packaging that acts as advertising. The verdict follows a similar judgment issued just two months prior, where the same court fined the clothing brand Khaadi for charging Rs 30 for branded bags under comparable circumstances.
Context and Wider Implications for Pakistani Consumers
This ruling highlights a growing judicial push in Pakistan to protect consumer rights by curbing unfair fees linked to promotional packaging. The precedent set by Peshawar’s Consumer Protection Court also reflects concurrent measures in Punjab, where the Environment Protection Agency has banned charging customers separately for plastic bags, with heavy fines for violations. Similar legal actions have occurred in Karachi and even across the border in India, signaling a regional trend against charging for branded shopping bags.
For Pakistani shoppers, this verdict is significant as it restricts retailers from passing on advertising costs to consumers through forced packaging charges. It bolsters transparency in pricing and reinforces consumer protection laws, encouraging fairer commercial practices across retail sectors.
As Judge Gandapur stated regarding the NDURE case, “Customers should not bear the cost of branded packaging that benefits the retailer commercially.” This principle may prompt other retailers to reconsider their packaging policies to avoid legal penalties.
